INSIDE OUTSIDE

Part 2: Approved Trees, Philadelphia


2026 (IN PROGRESS)


“We learned that we were planting the wrong trees.” 

The phrase ‘wrong trees’ has been rattling around in my mind since I heard him say this. ‘Him’ in this case being a city trees manager at a non-profit gardening organization in Philly that I briefly worked for that, perhaps not coincidentally, considered more than one thing ass backwards when it came to thinking about nature and the environment. I had accepted this when I heard it initially; I was speaking with someone whose knowledge and expertise I trusted, and it made sense that the ‘wrong trees’ in a city as dense and old as Philadelphia would grow large enough for branches to tangle in overhead powerlines, roots to break sidewalks and disrupt underground piping. 

But then I went to Savannah, Georgia for the first time in 2026. After taking in the live oaks and observing the reverent care for these spectacular specimens by the city of Savannah, it dawned on me that Philadelphia wasn’t planting the wrong trees, but is maybe thinking about trees wrong altogether.


 


Savannah, Georgia. 2026










How does our idea of “nature” — or nature itself — change when it is designed for fit around very human systems? 





The City of Philadelphia’s Approved Tree List is comprised of ornamental specimens selected to co-exist with Philly’s existing infrastructure. Above: (specimen name), max height 
Port Richmond neighborhood, Philadelphia. 

Above, left to right — Appoved Philadelphia tree specimens: Washington Hawthorn, Crataegus phaenopyrum, Shadblow Serviceberry, Amelanchier canadensis, Eastern Redbud, Cercis canadensis 











How does this highly controlled (and warped) interpretation of nature influence the human relationship with the natural world? 





MW: If I say landscape is always architecture, then it is always human exceptionalism too — but of a trickier kind. It sort of says: we literally shape plants and soil and topography as proof of the human. We’re going to use so-called nature as the proof that humans are not natural, are beyond or above nature ... A group of trees in a line, organized by humans, all slaves to the line, slaves to the human. There is nothing really living there, or only living like in a prison.

UŠ: I am against trees in cities only to produce shade for humans, without having been allowed to be trees. And all those formalisms, such as trees in a line, the symmetry, came from aristocratic gardens. In the repetition of the aristocratic formalist expressions in the public space, we made landscape useful for the eye only, rather than for living systems. Landscape architecture is not as ecological as it may seem either.

—  Urška Škerl interviewing Mark Wigley, Landzine









Updated 11.2026